9/11 Freedom Photography – Part 1 of 5

by Jim on 2011/09/22

[Jimbaux recorded that 9/11 was a beautiful day.]

Fighting The Oppressors

The cool, calm pre-dawn darkness of September 11 met him with an onerous sense of purpose.  He left early in the morning to embark on his mission, a mission he knew was far greater than himself.  While others slept and relaxed on this calm late summer morning, he knew that he’d be making a sacrifice on this day.  His efforts would be recorded for history as well, as he was not alone in his cause, for he had followers as well.  Furthermore, his cause was misunderstood by many, but the cause only existed because of threats to his way of life.

He knew that he had to do something, for to do nothing would be a defeat, a shameful submission to the forces of evil, the implementers of fear and intolerance, all disguised in benign guises.

Who Was He?

He was Mohammad Atta.  He was just as much Jimbaux exactly 10 years latter.  The eerie comparison to the former literally made the latter sick, and that’s no stretch of the truth.  I, Jimbaux, was honestly terrified, and I had slept very little the night before, being kept awake haunted by visions of myself being carted off to jail by the American Gestapo for taking pictures, and I would learn later that morning that such a fate came closer to befalling me in 2008 than I had then realized, but we’ll get to that, especially at the beginning of Part 2.

Ten years ago on this day, Mohammad Atta checked out of his hotel room in the predawn darkness to embark on his mission.  Exactly 10 years later, Jimbaux was on the road before dawn to embark on his own mission.  Like I said, especially with only two or three hours of sleep behind me, the comparison made me sick, but I knew logically that I was fighting back, fighting a good and noble fight, not just against the likes of Atta, but a more insidious enemy of fear and paranoia inside my own countrymen, those who seek to subvert our rights and freedoms.  In the discussions since my call to action for all photographers, someone said that it’s only a matter of time before some photographer gets shot and killed by police here in the United States, and I had been thinking the same thing myself.

Abortion Temptation

I must be honest and say that due to my lack of sleep, I was highly tempted to abort my mission and just sleep late that morning, but I had not only said publicly that I would be out taking pictures this morning, but I had called on others to do the same.  I really had no choice in the matter.  I was honor-bound and duty-bound to follow through with my plan, and that’s what I did.  What you see here today is Part 1 of the pictures from that day of duty and patriotism, a form of patriotism far deeper than wearing or waving a flag (which, one could argue, is not patriotic at all.)

An Appropriate First Target

“Target,” as Saint Jude told me later that day, might not be the best word to use when trying to show the harmlessness of railroad photography, but that’s what it is to me, and, when taking pictures of trains starting at dawn in New Orleans, there’s usually no better first target than Amtrak’s Crescent, and it was an especially appropriate target – maybe I should say “assignment” – this morning, as it is a passenger train bound for Washington, DC, and New York.

I really wanted to shoot the Crescent at the Wisner Boulevard overpass, a shot you’ve seen nailed by me last fall in “Back In The Saddle Saturday” in what seems like an eon ago, but the problem this morning was that that shot was jacked due to a train being parked on the southbound mainline, forcing me to look farther east for an opening shot.  There weren’t many options, so, as the train passed L&N Junction just before passing through the shadow of I-10, we begin our photographic adventures this morning unceremoniously at Franklin Avenue thus:

Yeah, I really should have just gone to Wisner anyway, since this shot also had a similar problem.  Oh, well.  Anyway, do you see the tracks coming from the right, merging with the NS tracks?  That, my friends, is the southwestern tip of the CSX Railway’s vast railroad empire.

Don’t forget that caption information for each of these shots can be found in the filename, which can be found by holding your mouse over the picture.

There were actually several New Orleans Police Department officers working the southern foot of the Franklin Avenue overpass due to early-morning services at the Franklin Avenue Baptist Church, and some of the officers can be seen in the distance in the below picture in the neutral ground.

The officers saw this white boy in his blue-and-white striped shirt (the same one I wore on the day that my rights were violated by the NOPD in 2008) climb the bridge with a big lens and did not overreact.  Anyway, the large Baptist Church is just to the left of the frame in the above picture.

Now What?

There were essentially two shots at Lake Ponchartrain that I could get of the Crescent, the first being the broadside from the Southshore that I last did nearly a year earlier.  The other choice is to go across the lake and shoot him from North Shore as he moved over the trestle, which is what I did.  This would make it much easier for me to drive into Slidell and do the depot shot there, but I hadn’t done either of these since the spring of 2010, and almost every one of these involves my tradition of stopping at the Starbucks in Slidell by the track after letting go of the train.  However, this was something I was scared to do for reasons we don’t need to discuss here.

Face All Of Your Fears, Jimbaux

I decided that I needed to man-up and just face all of my fears and just go back to the place that tradition was once mine to go.  Of course, first, there is the matter of photographing the train coming over the lake.  Oh, wait, let’s shoot the signal.

Okay, now, below, we begin shooting him coming through the drawbridge.  I think he had to stop and wait on a signal here.  You can see the US 11 bridge at left.

Now, lately, as many of you know, we’ve had some bad marsh fires in and around New Orleans.  What that means for the below picture is that you can barely see the skyline of downtown New Orleans at right, whereas it is normally more clearly visible.

Yeah, air pollution really sucks.  Anyway, here’s a view that’s a bit wider.

Above is the first of only two times on this whole day that I climbed atop the truck for a picture.

A New Shot

I’ve seen view several times as I’ve chased the train from here to Slidell, but I’ve never stopped to do this shot.  Well, I did now, and here it is.

How do you like it?  It’s different, isn’t it?


Slidell is the first station stop for the northbound Crescent.  It’s also the last station stop in Louisiana.  I got there just in the nick of time to get this shot.

I’ve never chased the Crescent past Slidell, even though I have shot it north of here when I was already by Slidell by this time of day.  Anyway, I saw the conductor hanging out of the starboard side of the train, and I snapped this shot of him.

Neat, eh?  It’s always good to get smiles from crewmen like this.

The Encounter With Federal Agents

As I’m walking away, I see a white a Ford Explorer (or Expedition) approaching the crossing with two uniformed men in the front.  Not wanting to even acknowledge that there might be a reason for me to interrupt the safe, harmless, and legal activity that I’m already doing myself, I merely continue walking to my truck.  I get inside my truck, and they pull up behind me, blocking me in.

Two federal agents were there to question me about why I was taking pictures of this train.  They were Amtrak police, and they were utmost professional.  Agent Bell merely asked me to show my ID, asked me if I liked trains, and asked me if I ever have had any pictures published (which allowed me to tell him about Jimbaux’s Journal.)  I told him about why I was out on this day.  He seemed to have no problem with this.  He merely told me that there were Amtrak and Norfolk Southern special agents all up and down the track on this day, and that I was therefore likely to encounter more badges.

The conversation wasn’t very extensive, and there was not the remotest bit of unprofessionalism in Agent Bell’s actions.  I actually told him that I felt reassured that he and his associate were out on duty on this day.

He bid me farewell, and he went back to his truck to leave.  I went back to mine too.  That “should” have been the end of the conversation, but I turned around and went back to his vehicle in an effort to avoid a confrontation later in the day, and giving him a professional courtesy.  He saw me approaching him, and he got back out of his vehicle.  I said, “hey, if you get a call later on about someone shooting pictures off of the broad street overpass,” that it would likely be yours truly.  I figured that telling him that would make both his day and my day easier.  In all honesty, though, I told him this with some hesitation, because I’m not obligated to let anyone know what I was doing.  However, as you can see, he had earned my trust.  As it turns out, when I heard his response to my statement that triggered his memeory, it was the beginning of realizing that I owed him far more trust than I had realized.

A Blast From The Past, And New Information About The 2008 Incident

“Oh, you were the guy I rescued from the NOPD a few years ago,” weren’t the exact words out of his mouth, but it was something to that effect.


As it eventuated, the conversation that ensued was far more revealing and lengthy than the conversation that preceded it.  As it turns out, Agent Bell was involved in the 2008 Broad Street incident, and, as we will learn next time when I discuss our conversation, he was something of a savior to me then, and his use of the word “rescue” is really revealing.  I am simultaneously bothered and reassured by it.  Why?  We’ll learn more next time, now that I have learned another side of the 2008 incident.

Stay tuned.



1 Marcelo Benoit September 22, 2011 at 00:45

Great pictures! I am waiting for the next parts!

2 Joy September 22, 2011 at 10:17

Nice job, I like the lake photos. I wonder what is so incredibly intimidating about a DSLR camera, when we’re in a world where everyone carries a camera around all the time. Surely the real terrorists have caught onto this mentality and are out snapping shots and videos with their iPhones…..

3 Jim September 22, 2011 at 14:20

Really liked that new shot you posted. The light shows the differences between the coaches, diner, sleepers and the baggage car really well. The color in the photo with the contrast between the bright train and the trees and plants makes it pop out.

4 Patrick September 22, 2011 at 15:06

I was shooting at NS Norris Yard in Birmingham on 09/11/11, and a train crew warned me that they had been instructed to report anyone with a camera or hanging out near the tracks that day. I thanked them, grabbed shots of the FerroMex GEvo, and headed on east to Atlanta.

When I lived in New Orleans (95-99, 2001-2004), the CSX and NS agents were great. It was the Harbor Police and NOPD that hassled me on occasion at Gentilly Yard.

5 Howard Bunte September 22, 2011 at 15:24

as ever… a fine piece of work… in particular, I like the contrasts in pic. 3… the ‘greyed light’ and the glint off the steel rails…nice.

6 Todd September 22, 2011 at 18:30

You seem to have a real problem with authority and go out looking for confrontations.

7 EDITOR - Jimbaux September 22, 2011 at 20:13

Todd, first, thank you for participating in Jimbaux’s Journal.

It’s quite unfortunate that you have that skewed perception of things, as that kind of thinking is the very reason why our rights are allowed to be threatened as they are. You seemed to have ignored several things that I have written just in this post, like the fact that I told Agent Bell that I felt reassured by his presence on the railroad that day, the fact that I gave them the courtesy of letting them know that I’d be performing my safe, legal, and harmless activities later that afternoon at the ‘sensitive’ area of Broad Street, the fact that these activities are indeed safe, legal, and harmless, the fact that this is about the dozenth time I’ve chased the Crescent from New Orleans to Slidell, all without law enforcement encounters until this day.

Most of all, you seem to have forgotten that I have a passion for both photography and for railroads, which leads me to photograph railroad activity. There are issues of both freedom of the press and freedom of expression here, and unlike with, say, graffiti, there aren’t issues of violation of private property rights.

Your statement of my “real problem with authority” is misplaced. I don’t have a problem with authority per se, but I do have a huge problem with abuse of authority, of which I have before been a victim, but not on this day, since S. A. Bell and his companion did not abuse any of their authorities. They had not only the right but also an obligation to question me.

Believe me; as an educator, I see lack of respect for an authority as an appalling problem. Breakdowns of discipline and fears of being perceived as targeting different segments of the population have resulted in public schools that are basically factories whose main products are menaces to society, sometimes educated savages.

I also find your statements somewhat hilarious since, 10 years ago, just before and even for a month after the 9/11 attacks, I was about as straight-laced and docile as one could be concerning authority. In some ways, that’s good, because that rigidity prevented me (not completely, but quite close) in my youth of doing some reckless stuff. It became bad when I took too much of that rigidity into adulthood, which prevented me from thinking that I didn’t actually deserve being yelled at and harassed for doing the safe, legal, and harmless things of which I am passionate.

That seems to bring us back to your perception. Was I looking for a confrontation? Not quite, but I knew that one was likely to happen. That’s not why I went out on 9/11 to take pictures, though. I was standing up for our rights to do this, as you don’t seem to understand. So, I was indeed looking for an opportunity to stand up for all of our rights. As I’ve written before on this site, I’m not one who is often inclined to turn things into global issues, and I’m even often repulsed when people do that, but this is something that due to negative personal experience I had to take a stand and hold my ground. So, although your statements were misplaced, there actually are some small grains of truth to both of the things that you said.

It’s the very sentiment that you express that causes people to unfortunately think of me as some brazen, daring renegade for “daring” to do something that is safe, legal, harmless, and my passion too. Remember, photography is not a crime, and it should not be. I was standing up for my rights as well as yours.

Again, when I was a kid, I wouldn’t dare challenge authority or convention. My evolution to the person you perceive me to be was a slow one that really began in the wake of 9/11 and got accelerated with the incidents that happened to me and with similar incidents I’ve read from other people.

I suggest you rethink your reasons for how you arrived at your perception of my actions.

Lastly, again, thank you for participating in Jimbaux’s Journal.

8 Todd September 23, 2011 at 16:39

Why are you even on this forum? Everything that you post is in the south or New Orleans.

9 Whitney September 25, 2011 at 15:46

If you don’t like Jimbaux’s perspective on New Orleans or the South, why do you spend your energy reading and responding to his posts? Stop trolling and crawl back under your rock, please!

Keep it coming, Jimbaux!

10 Ken Parnell November 13, 2011 at 12:55

Jimbaux, my name is Ken Parnell. I am that conductor that you captured in the above photo. I want to say thank you for the positive exposure to what we do. As a young conductor with Amtrak, I seek to restore the image of conductor as a friendly member of the communities that we ride through and on the train. So I thank you for your continued service.

11 judy-thorne November 13, 2011 at 19:30

I agree with Whitney. Take your trolling elsewhere, Todd.

12 mike November 14, 2011 at 02:42

Great job jimbaux ,thanks for shooting 745 , Todd it seems to me you have nothing good to say about anything nor anyone.

13 Tom Becket November 14, 2011 at 12:09

Seems like Todd has built a fan base!!

Glad to see Ken Parnell on here-the Amtrak conductor. I appreciate his attitude, and hope that his career is productive and rewarding. Don’t let the politics-of Amtrak, Homeland Security, the budget, etc-get you down.

14 Angeline Castilloux September 7, 2013 at 07:24

Jimbaux, don’t ever compare yourself with the likes of Mohammed Atta. He was nothing more than a drone following an ideology based on hatred.

Comments on this entry are closed.

{ 7 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: